There are concepts and underlying notions within the book that I take issue with. I will not comment about those other than to say for the most part they have to do mostly with 1) what William Young records as Mack's vision of God's appearance, and 2) a tendency for the story to seem somewhat reactionary to the abuses of mankind in the name of religion.
The theology that Mack comes away with has merit and is worthy of consideration. Specifically in three areas.
- God is interested in a dynamic relationship with man. There are many passage of Scripture that emphasize this same point, beginning at the beginning. In the Garden of Eden man had free access to God and God to man. Man however acted independent of God and broke the relationship. He began to hide himself from God. God walked in the cool of the day looking for man. Knowing that sin damaged His relationship with man, He, through Jesus, began to provide a way for the restoration of that relationship. In the prophets God says what He desires is for man to "do justice, love kindness, and to walk humbly" with Him (Micah 6:8). In his second epistle to Thessalonians, Paul tells them that those who KNOW God will escape condemnation. Knowing God is having relationship with Him.
- Jesus is God: Mack's previous concept of God was that God the father was mean and controlling whereas God the Son was gracious, loving and understanding. This changes for Mack when he really gets to know God and see the scars on His wrist match the scars on Jesus. The words of Jesus plainly speak the same. In words of comfort to His disciples, Jesus says, "If you have known Me, you would have known the Father . . ." Jn 14:7ff. A real relationship with Jesus is a real relationship with God and the Spirit. They are truly one in purpose, emotion, and action, even if they sometimes seem to act independently.
- God and suffering. Mr. Young and Mr. Philips record words as coming from God, and they summarize the understanding of God's involvement in the world in a way I cannot, but in a way that I believe to be accurate in many ways. God says, " . . . just because I work incredible good out of unspeakable tragedies doesn't mean I orchestrate the tragedies. Don't ever assume that my using something means I caused it or that I needed it to accomplish my purposes. That will only lead you to false notions about me. Grace does not depend on suffering to exist, but where there is suffering you will find grace in many facets and colors." (pp. 187-188).
Overall this book was a great read.